Archeology Petra and Mecca – Islam kahan paida hua

Archaeology Petra and Mecca – Modern research on the archeological history of Islam is revealing that the origin of Islam took place in Petra rather than Mecca. Though this theory needs more proof, one thing is evident that Mecca seriously lacks the archeological evidence for Establishing the origin of Islam. Clip from Ghalib Kamal Live Episode 17

Ghalib Kamal – Pakistani Freethinkers

8 Comments
  1. Afif Khaja 8 months ago

    Normally, I don’t give much weight to conspiracy theories because they tend to lack evidence. The mainstream view and what I have always heard since birth is that Makkah of Muhammad is in Saudi Arabia. However, once I watched Dan Gibson’s documentary on the origins of Islam, the evidence became compelling to me. Gibson showed that for the first 100 years after Muhammad’s death, all of the mosques pointed to Petra and not Makkah. Also, Petra is a much older city than Makkah and has the idol worship places that Makkah lacks (temples of Dushera and Hubal). It also has the foundations of a building that match the proportions of the Ka’bah exactly, unlike the current Ka’bah in Makkah which is a perfect cube. The problem is that all of the sources of history we have, starting from Ibn Ishaq (786) clearly mention that Makkah is in Saudi Arabia. These can be explained by the fact that the books we have today were written more than 150 years after Muhammad’s death. I am leaning towards Petra being the origin of Islam when looked at from a neutral perspective but I want Gibson’s work and evidences to be rigorously examined by archaeologists and for his work to be accepted in the mainstream.

  2. Ahmed 7 months ago

    Ibn Abbas nai koi kitab nai likhi thi.

    Aap kaisai itni thori knowledge kai sath itnai important questions ka answer dhoontai hain.

  3. Saifullah 7 months ago

    This Is An Utter Trash And False, Many Western Academics Like Sean Anthony (Expert In Early Islam.) And Marijn van Putten (Dutch Quranic Linguist) And Many Others Such As Apostate Prophet (Ridvan Aydemir) Take Dan Gibson’s Work As A Joke.

    • Shiddhant 5 months ago

      Saifu if the writers work is joke than show the evidence and prove them wrong . But no, your type people is blind followers of Mohammed, who had sex with 9 year old girl .

  4. Shiddhant 5 months ago

    Galib Kamal sir these Muslims will never accept the truth. If they can, they would have done it before 1400 year. Galib sir this is good that Dean Gibson did it in Saudi Arabia, if he did the same thing in India, he would have brutally murdered by Islamic terrorists.

  5. bluray 2 weeks ago

    You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will agree with your website. Malorie Arney Orvah

  6. JamesCunse 2 weeks ago

    cheap erectile dysfunction http://canadaedwp.com male dysfunction

  7. free porn 4 days ago

    Wonderful post! We are linking to this great content on our website. Keep up the good writing. Drucy Simmonds Hillary

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

©Ghalib Kamal 2020

Log in with your credentials

Forgot your details?